There is nothing much better for a litigator/baseball fan than when these two interests collide.  One of the highpoints of my legal career was successfully representing a major league baseball player (Pat Kelly) in his salary arbitration with the Yankees.  So I was pretty excited when the case Olson, et al. v. Major League Baseball, et al.  was filed this year in the SDNY.  Maybe not as excited as if I would have been if I were involved in the case myself, but in these times we have to take what we can get.

Olson was a putative class action brought by individuals who participated in DraftKings fantasy baseball competitions.   The plaintiffs sued Major League Baseball ("MLB"), MLB's marketing entity called Major League Baseball Advanced Media, L.P. ("MLBAM"), the Houston Astros and the Boston Red Sox alleging that plaintiffs' fantasy baseball efforts had been harmed by virtue of the electronic sign-stealing scandal that has been revealed over the past few months.  In a nutshell, the Astros were found to have devised a system using cameras to relay the signs the opposing team's catcher was giving to its pitcher by sending the signs to a player or coach situated behind the Astros dugout.  The recipient of the video would then convey the pitch information to the batter by banging on a trash can.   It is undoubtedly true that a batter's knowledge of the pitch about to be thrown enhances his chances of a successful time at the plate.  While sign-stealing is not in and of itself illegal (it's a time honored tradition for baserunners to try to figure out the sign being given by the catcher and then convey that information to the batter), the rules of baseball specifically prohibit electronic sign stealing. 

The plaintiffs alleged that MLB and the various defendants were aware of the sign stealing scheme but did nothing to stop it.  One reason for this, the plaintiffs alleged, is that there are sponsorship and other financial relationships between MLBAM and major league baseball teams with DraftKings.  Plaintiffs brought a nationwide class action alleging fraud, negligence, and unjust enrichment claims as well as violations of state consumer protection statutes.

Last week, a federal district court in the Southern District of New York (Rakoff, J.) dismissed all of the plaintiffs' claims.  The decision is attached here.  To summarize, the court rejected plaintiffs' assertion that the MLB had committed fraud and/or other torts by making general statements about baseball's commitment to integrity or specific comments about the conduct of the Astros or other teams.  Most of the allegedly fraudulent statements set forth in the complaint were found not to have been false (e.g., statements by the commissioner of baseball that maintaining the integrity of baseball was the highest priority).  And those that might have been false or misleading (e.g., denials by the teams involved that they had cheated) were not actionable because the plaintiffs could not adequately allege that they had relied on these statements when deciding to participate in the fantasy baseball competition.  The court also rejected the claim that defendants' conduct had violated state consumer protection laws, noting that plaintiffs had failed to allege with any specificity that they ever heard or saw the alleged misrpresentations.  And, in any event, the court found that plaintiffs had not sufficiently alleged a nexus between the supposed misrepresentations and the transactions that purportedly caused the harm to the plaintiffs' efforts to prevail in their fantasy baseball endeavors.

In his decision, Judge Rakoff did not go out of his way to discuss the impact on sports and other competitions if unhappy fans or fantasy participants are permitted to litigate their complaints.  But suits like Olson are not unprecedented.   Fans have tried, but been unsuccessful, in pursuing suits against the National Football League arising from such events as the infamous blown call by the referees in the 2019 NFC title game that cost the New Orleans Saints a trip to the Super Bowl and over the alleged secret videotaping of opponents by the New England Patriots.   

In the Olson  case, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' claims in its entirety.  It did note that while a few of the named deficiencies might be curable with an amended complaint, most could not.  Thus it appears that if the plaintiffs want their fantasy to continue, they are going to have to take it to the Second Circuit.

The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) includes specific programs sponsored by the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) designed to provide economic relief for those small business concerns that have been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic. President Donald Trump signed the act into law on March 27, 2020.

What Programs Are Available?

  • Available Immediately – Economic Injury Disaster Loans (EIDL). The CARES Act expanded upon the SBA's EIDL program by providing $10 billion in funding for disaster loans related to the coronavirus.
    • All 50 states and all of their counties have been declared economically impacted areas and are eligible for the disaster loans. Applicants apply directly through the SBA for the disaster loans which may be for a maximum amount of $2 million and applicants can receive emergency funding of $10,000 within three days of the application submission.
    • The $10,000 emergency funding is not required to be repaid, even if the applicant is ultimately denied the disaster loan by the SBA. The term of the loan is for a maximum of 30 years at an interest rate not to exceed 3.75 percent for small businesses.
  • Available Immediately – SBA Express Loans. The CARES Act increased the maximum amount that an applicant may borrow on the existing SBA Express Loans program. From March 27, 2020, through Dec. 31, 2020, a borrower may have a line of credit under the SBA Express Loans program up to the maximum amount of $1 million. On Jan. 1, 2021, the maximum amount allowed under these loans will revert back to its original amount of $350,000. The SBA Express Loans are in the form of a working capital line of credit.
  • Available as of April 3, 2020. The CARES Act created a new forgivable SBA 7a loan program by providing $349 billion in funding to the SBA for the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans. The purpose of these loans is to help employers make payroll and other operational costs such as rent, utilities and interest on existing loans.
    • An applicant may obtain a loan not to exceed the lesser of $10 million and 2.5 times its average monthly payroll as determined in accordance with the CARES Act. All interest and principal fees on the loan are deferred for six months. Borrower does not pay any fees.
    • The principal amount, and any interest related thereto, of the loan and used for payroll and other approved purposes is forgivable as long as the employer maintains certain employment and wage levels; provided, that payroll costs must account for 75 percent of the forgiven principal amount. The applicant must apply for forgiveness and provide the appropriate documentation as set forth by the SBA.
    • Any remaining principal amount after the application of the forgiveness shall mature two years from the date of the origination of the loan and shall have an interest rate of 1 percent. The prepayment penalty for PPP loans has been waived.

Do I Qualify?

Qualifications for EIDL. To qualify for the EIDL program, a business needs to either 1) qualify under the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 632) as a small business concern, private nonprofit organization or small agricultural cooperatives, 2) be a business with not more than 500 employees, 3) be an individual who operates under a sole proprietorship (with or without employees) or an independent contractor, 4) be a cooperative with not more than 500 employees, 5) be an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) as defined in Section 3 of the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 632) with not more than 500 employees, or 6) be a tribal business concern, as described in Section 31(b)(2)(C) of the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 657a(b)(2)(C)) with not more than 500 employees, during the covered period beginning on Jan. 31, 2020, and ending on Dec. 31, 2020.

The SBA has waived the requirement that the applicant must have been in business for the one year period before the disaster, requiring only that the business have been in operation on Jan. 31, 2020. Additionally, the requirement for the applicant having not been able to obtain credit elsewhere has been waived. The SBA may approve an applicant based solely on its credit score and shall not require a tax return or a tax return transcript or the SBA may use alternative methods to determine an applicant's ability to repay the loan. No personal guarantee is required for loans of not more than $200,000 during the covered period. The SBA requires collateral for loans over $25,000 but has noted that the lack of collateral will NOT disqualify an applicant.

Qualifications for SBA Express Loans. To qualify for a SBA Express Loan, a business needs to qualify under the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 632) as a small business concern, operate for profit, engage in operation within the U.S., and be in operation for at least two years. Additionally, the applicant must be able to prove/show a need for financing, have already financed the business through alternative means, show the funds will be used for sound business purposes, have no delinquencies on previous debts to the government and generally have a credit score at least 600.

Qualifications for the Paycheck Protection Program. During the covered period beginning on Feb. 15, 2020, and ending on June 30, 2020, to qualify a business needs to:

  • Be a business concern, nonprofit organization (501(c)(3)), veterans organization, or tribal business concern as described in Section 31(b)(2)(C) of the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 657a(b)(2)(C)) that (a) qualifies as a small business concern under current SBA employee-based or revenue-based size standards corresponding to its primary industry, or (b) meets both tests in SBA's "alternative-size standard" as of March 27, 2020, or (c) employs not more than 500 employees whose principal residence is in the United States.
  • Be a sole proprietorship, independent contractor or eligible self-employed individual (as defined in Section 7002(b) of the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (Public Law 116-127)).

The following exceptions apply:

  • Business concerns with more than one physical location which employ not more than 500 employees whose principal residence is in the United States per physical location and are in the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) code designation beginning with 72 (accommodation and food service) shall be eligible to receive PPP loan;
  • The provisions applicable to affiliations are waived for the following: 1) any business concern with not more than 500 employees whose principal residence is in the United States that is in the NAICS code designation beginning with 72 (accommodation and food service), 2) any business concern operating as a franchise that is assigned a franchise identifier by the SBA, and 3) any business concern that receives financial assistance from a company licensed under Section 301 of the Small Business Investment Act of 1958 (15 U.S.C. 681), and 4) the existing affiliation exemption applicable to tribal business concerns.
  • For information related to religious institutions, see Holland & Knight's previous alert "SBA Releases Supplemental CARES Act Guidance for Religious Institutions," April 7, 2020.
  • For information related to guidance for venture capital-backed companies, see Holland & Knight's previous alert "Guidance for VC-Backed Companies Seeking SBA Paycheck Protection Program Loans Under CARES Act," April 6, 2020.

What Do We Know About The Process?

To Apply for an EIDL: Applicants apply directly with the SBA for an EIDL. Applicants will need to complete an SBA loan application (SBA Form 5); a Schedule of Liabilities (SBA Form 2202) and a Personal Financial Statement (SBA Form 413). In the event that the SBA is not able to approve the applicant solely on its credit score or some alternative method, the applicant should be prepared to provide its Federal Income Tax Return or Tax Transcript. Additionally, the applicant may need to provide a current year-to-date profit-and-loss statement and/or an Additional Filing Requirements (SBA Form 1368) providing monthly sales figures. An applicant may request an emergency grant in an amount not greater than $10,000 when it applies and the SBA will provide that grant within three days of the application (note, this grant does not need to be repaid, even if the applicant is denied the loan). If approved for the loan, the applicant does not need to accept it.

To Apply for an SBA Express Loan: Applicants apply directly with a lender (a bank or financing company). Borrower will need to provide a Borrower Information Form (SBA Form 1919) and any other information or requirements as set forth by the lender with whom they are applying. The lender has the ability to make the eligibility and creditworthiness determination. The SBA will respond within 36 hours of receiving the documentation from the lender. No collateral is required for loans of up to $25,000. For loans greater than $25,000, lenders are allowed to use their own existing collateral policy.

To Apply for the Paycheck Protection Program: The application window opened on April 3, 2020, for small businesses and sole proprietorships, and will open on April 10, 2020, for independent contractors and self-employed individuals. Applicants are encouraged to move quickly, as there is a funding cap and the program is expected to be oversubscribed. Fortunately, the application form is only four pages and is relatively straightforward.

Funds are provided in the form of loans that will be fully forgiven when used for payroll costs, interest on mortgages, rent and utilities (amount of loan forgiveness is based on the employer maintaining or quickly rehiring employees and maintaining salary levels). The SBA has capped the mount of nonpayroll costs that may be forgiven to 25 percent of the total forgiven amount. Interest and principal loan payments will also be deferred for six months. No collateral or personal guarantees are required. Neither the government nor lenders will charge small businesses any fees.

Companies can apply through any existing SBA 7(a) lender or through any federally insured depository institution, federally insured credit union, and Farm Credit System institution that is participating. Other regulated lenders will be available to make these loans once they are approved and enrolled in the program. Companies should consult with their local lender as to whether it is participating. All loans will have the same terms regardless of lender or borrower. A list of participating lenders as well as additional information and full terms can be found on the SBA website.

Preparing to Apply: An applicant can take the following steps to put itself in a position to be ready to apply for a loan:

  • fill out the Paycheck Protection Program Application Form
  • determine eligibility either under the expanded eligibility set forth in the CARES Act, the Interim Final Rule and any additional guidance
  • calculate your potential maximum loan amount through utilization of the average monthly payroll costs as set forth in the CARES Act, the Interim Final Rule and any additional guidance
  • communicate with your existing lenders to ensure that if your existing loan documentation requires a waiver, consent or amendment for you to be able to obtain a PPP loan, you have already had the discussions with your existing lenders and started any required documentation
  • be prepared to provide the lender any additional information it may require on the ownership and structure of the applicant, the payroll calculation of the applicant and anything else the lender may need to determine eligibility and approve the loan

What Steps Can I Take Now?

In connection with the steps set forth above:

Step 1: Conduct an initial company assessment with available resources. If you have specific SBA eligibility or affiliation questions, you can reach out to COVIDSBA@hklaw.com.

Step 2: Reach out to your banking relationships to determine which banks with whom you have a relationship will be participating as a lender for the PPP and to determine what, if any, steps you may need to take related to any existing loans you have.

Step 3: If you believe you may be eligible, begin to complete the current application for the SBA Paycheck Protection Program and begin gathering information in preparation for the application.

Step 4: Most important, keep yourself, your employees and your families safe and healthy.

What Should I Avoid?

Congress and the SBA understand the urgency with which this funding is needed to support small businesses, and have not attached many strings. That said, there are several important considerations to keep in mind to ensure your company's loan request is met.

First, because these loans will be forgiven if companies maintain all of their employees at their normal salaries (including benefits), companies should avoid layoffs, and/or rehire any employees that were recently released. Then, once the loan is disbursed, companies should avoid using funds for any unauthorized purposes, lest they open themselves up to allegations of fraud or receive a smaller percentage of loan forgiveness. Beyond those two requirements, as long as the company stays out of bankruptcy and hasn't defaulted on a previous SBA loan, potential pitfalls are minimal.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.