Nigeria: Environment And Social Governance (ESG): Implication For In-House Counsel

Mr. Uche Val Obi SAN, Ngozi Chinwa Ole, Daniel Anagu¹

1. INTRODUCTION

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations are now crucial in determining how multinational corporations operate globally, and they have a big impact on the duties and role of in-house counsel. For in-house counsel, this means dealing with an environment where their role expands beyond traditional legal advice to include ESG strategy integration, compliance with evolving regulations and oversight of corporate sustainability initiatives. The latter is the same globally including Germany, Denmark, Singapore, Greece, Sweden, United States, Oman etc. In these jurisdictions and across the board, in-house counsel are at the forefront of understanding how environmental, social and governance criteria have an impact on regulatory risks, corporate reputations as well as stakeholder relationships to guide their organisations towards a complex framework for sustainable business practices.

2. KEY ASPECTS OF ESG FOR IN-HOUSE COUNSEL

The environmental component of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) centres around an organization's commitment to safeguarding natural resources. Examples encompass concerns such as climate change, biodiversity conservation, energy efficiency, air and water quality, as well as the prevention of depletion of natural resources. A pivotal moment highlighting the significance of these environmental factors occurred in May 2021, when the Dutch environmental group Milieudefensie, along with other NGOs and thousands of individual plaintiffs, sued Royal Dutch Shell plc (Shell) in the Hague District Court. The lawsuit argued that Shell's global CO2 emissions contributed to climate change and violated the Dutch duty of care owed to citizens. The court delivered a landmark decision in favour of Milieudefensie, ordering Shell to reduce its global CO2 emissions by 45% by 2030 compared to 2019 levels.

Social factors within the ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) framework revolve around an organization's conduct and relationships with individuals. Instances encompass the organization's relationships with both global and local communities, customer contentment, engagement and relations with employees, and upholding human rights and labour standards. A notable illustration of the impact of social factors emerged with the introduction of California Senate Bill 826. This legislation imposes gender and racial/ethnic diversity quotas for corporate boards of directors of publicly traded companies headquartered in California. This instance underscores the intersection of social considerations with corporate governance, reflecting a broader societal push for inclusivity and diversity within the highest echelons of corporate leadership. It serves as a poignant example of how regulatory measures can influence and shape social dynamics within the corporate landscape, emphasizing the evolving expectations for companies to prioritize diversity and equality in their organizational structures.

Governance factors scrutinize how a corporation governs itself, emphasizing internal control systems and practices to ensure adherence to regulations. Examples encompass company leadership, the composition and diversity of the board, whistleblower programs, executive compensation and policies, as well as contributions and involvement in political lobbying. In Re Tesla, Inc. Stockholder Derivative Litigation, Tesla shareholders filed a lawsuit against the company's board of directors, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty. They claimed the board:

• Failed to adequately oversee Elon Musk, Tesla's CEO, and his actions. This included concerns about his conduct on social media and potential conflicts of interest.
• Approved an excessive compensation package for Musk. The shareholders argued the package, heavily reliant on stock options, wasn't performance-based and enriched Musk at the expense of the company.

The Delaware Court of Chancery, in a decision rendered on June 3, 2023, dismissed the lawsuit, providing a comprehensive perspective on the crucial aspects:

• Board Oversight: The court found the board actively engaged in overseeing Musk, despite acknowledging "challenges" arising from his unique personality and leadership style. They highlighted actions like establishing committees, negotiating limitations on his compensation, and adopting governance reforms.
• Compensation Package: The court determined the compensation package, while significant, wasn't unreasonable given Musk's "extraordinary contributions" to Tesla's success. They considered factors like stock price growth, market competition for talent, and potential benefits to the company.

Consequently, embracing ESG is not just a legal imperative but a strategic opportunity for organizations to build resilience, enhance reputation, and contribute positively to the broader societal and environmental challenges we face. Thus, in-house counsel play a pivotal role as it implies that they must expand their role and expertise, ensure compliance and risk management, and navigate complex stakeholder relationships.

3. IMPLICATION OF ESG FOR IN-HOUSE COUNSEL

Expanded Role and Expertise

As the demand for ESG considerations intensifies, in-house counsel must broaden their roles and expertise. Their responsibilities extend from traditional legal risk management to becoming strategic partners in the integration of sustainable and ethical practices. This evolution positions in-house counsel as indispensable contributors to corporate success in an era where ESG considerations increasingly shape business trajectories.

Compliance and Risk Management

As the regulatory spotlight deepens on Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) matters, in-house counsel become linchpins in guaranteeing organizational adherence to pertinent laws and regulations. Their key role extends to identifying and adeptly managing risks related to ESG, encompassing intricate areas like climate change regulations, labour practices, and corporate governance standards. This demands a proactive approach, where in-house counsel not only navigate the evolving legal landscape but also strategically mitigate potential risks, ensuring their organizations align with ESG principles.

Corporate Strategy and Reporting

The evolving landscape of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors brings a significant implication for in-house counsel, especially in the realms of corporate strategy and reporting. As strategic advisors, in-house counsel are increasingly tasked with ensuring that ESG commitments are seamlessly integrated into the fabric of corporate strategies, operational practices, and business models. This crucial role involves not only aligning ESG initiatives with legal standards but also weaving them into the organization's overarching goals and values.

Furthermore, in-house counsel are at the forefront of enhancing transparency in ESG reporting. They bear the critical responsibility of overseeing the preparation and dissemination of accurate and comprehensive ESG disclosures in annual reports and other public documents. This aspect of their role is crucial in meeting the escalating demands for transparency from a broad spectrum of stakeholders, including regulators, investors, and consumers. The implication here is clear: in-house counsel are central to navigating the complexities of ESG compliance and reporting, ensuring that their organizations not only adhere to current regulations but also proactively communicate their ESG efforts and achievements.

Stakeholder's Engagement

In the context of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) concerns, the role of in-house counsel extends significantly into the domain of stakeholder engagement. The growing expectation for businesses to proactively address ESG issues necessitates that in-house counsel adeptly manage and navigate the intricate web of relationships with various stakeholders, such as shareholders, regulators, customers, and the broader community. This complex role involves advising on and crafting nuanced communication strategies that effectively convey the organisation's stance and progress on sensitive ESG matters.

In-house counsel are instrumental in orchestrating these dialogues, ensuring that the communication not only aligns with the company's ESG commitments but also resonates with stakeholder values and expectations. Additionally, they occupy a crucial position in mitigating reputational risks associated with ESG challenges. By engaging stakeholders transparently and constructively, in-house counsel facilitate a two-way dialogue that can preemptively address concerns and foster a positive organizational reputation in the realm of ESG performance.

Litigation and Legal Risks

As Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors gain prominence, in-house counsel are at the forefront of reducing legal risks and litigation. Due to the growing importance of ESG concerns, these counsel must not only foresee future legal difficulties but also take proactive steps to avoid them. They are specifically responsible for foreseeing and preparing for litigation risks about social welfare breaches, environmental damage, and governance shortcomings with ESG problems.

In-house counsel are essential in this terrain because they develop and carry out strategies to reduce legal weaknesses. This entails getting ready for increased scrutiny and possible legal challenges from the public, regulatory agencies, and activists, among others. The conclusion is obvious: in-house counsel play a critical role in protecting their companies from the legal repercussions of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) challenges by making sure that legal strategies keep pace with the changing legal environment.

Ethical Leadership and Culture

ESG (environmental, social, and governance) principles place a premium on moral leadership, and in-house lawyers play a critical role in fostering an ESG-integrated corporate culture. Beyond merely complying, they must actively mould their organizations' moral compass. Inhouse counsel are responsible for assisting their organizations in developing and implementing moral decision-making procedures, handling situations involving conflicts of interest, and developing governance frameworks that give sustainability, diversity, equity, and inclusion a top priority.

The consequence is clear: in-house counsel actively contribute to the ethical development of their companies and are change agents as well as ESG compliance enforcers. Through the demonstration and advancement of ESG principles, they open the door for a corporate culture that goes beyond legal mandates and cultivates a climate of honesty, accountability, and conformity with societal norms. In this role, in-house counsel are crucial in guiding their companies not only toward compliance with the law but also toward moral leadership and an environment that is firmly based on ESG principles.

Mergers, Acquisitions, and Investments

The incorporation of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) standards into investment, merger, and acquisition decisions is a significant change in the corporate environment that directly affects in-house counsel. Their responsibilities have grown to encompass a thorough evaluation of ESG opportunities and risks at these crucial decision-making stages. This means performing extensive due diligence to examine the target companies' ESG performance and make sure that investment strategies and valuation models take ESG factors into account. This trend emphasizes how in-house counsel' roles are changing and places them in a pivotal role in steering their companies toward sustainable investment and responsible growth. Inhouse counsel contribute to a future where business investments are assessed not just on their financial returns but also on their impact on society and the environment by integrating ESG issues into the core of financial decision-making. This strategy reaffirms companies' dedication to upholding ESG values and reflects a larger trend toward sustainable business practices that support international initiatives to solve social and environmental issues.

4. CONCLUSION

The emergence of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors has brought about a significant transformation in the function of in-house counsel. Their duties have surpassed providing typical legal assistance to include overseeing sustainability, integrating ESG strategies, and complying with regulations. They play a critical role in helping their companies navigate the complicated ESG environment, deal with legal issues, improve corporate governance, guarantee moral leadership, and interact with a wide range of stakeholders. These days, in-house attorneys are essential in helping companies integrate ESG principles into their strategy and corporate cultures, controlling reputational risks, and guiding their growth in an environmentally conscious and sustainable manner. Their efforts are essential to bringing corporate operations into line with social and environmental standards, providing a crucial chance for moral leadership and long-term growth in the business sector.

Footnote

1. Mr Uche Val Obi SAN, Ngozi Chinwa Ole and Daniel Anagu are the Managing Partner, Managing Associate (Consultant) and Associate of Alliance Law Firm respectively.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.